5 stars for design pattern, 2 stars for fit. I run between L & XL so I started with an XL. Shoulder seams were 3" outside of my shoulder, sleeves were 3"-4" too long. Was hoping for some shrinking but after 8-10 washes still way too big. Love the pattern so I purchased a large online. Shoulder seams now 2" outside my shoulders, sleeves 2+" too long. Nice thick material and the fit at my waist is just right. Crazy Shirts in Whaler's village at Kaanapali, HI is outstanding as was the online purchasing experience. Just wish the shirt was more accurate proportioned